
If hockey goonery is your cup of tea, then the Four-Nations mini-tournament between the United States and Canada certainly provided. As much off the ice as on. Beyond the fairly predictable player fights—that’s hockey!—leading up to the championship final were the partisan fans booing the opposing national anthems, triggered by the gasbag Trump administration’s belittling of Canadian prime minister Justin Trudeau and his sovereign nation—“soon to be known as governor of our 51st state.”
Canadian fans, in the end, weren’t shy about interpreting their Four Nations title as a triumph over their potential “11th Province,” and Trudeau got in his shot by declaring, “You can’t take our country—and you can’t take our game.” At the title joust, singer Chantal Kreviazuk made her own statement regarding independence by massaging a line in “O Canada!” from “in all our command” to “that only us command.”
But, too—and this saved the event—there was the best of the sport’s delightful, excruciatingly entertaining on-the-fly drama, and a respectful acknowledgement by players on both sides that the sport survived the political toxicity to cultivate new fans. There was the traditional post-championship handshake, hockey’s unique version of respect and diplomacy.
The final was the fourth most-watched NHL-affiliated game in history and biggest draw since the modern Nielsen era began in 1988.
Certainly, there was the reminder that sports always is political and that national rivalries add plenty of juice. For the Empire State Building and Toronto’s CN Tower to be lit up in the championship combatants‘ respective national colors was a nice touch, even as real hockey fans—while taking their patriotic sides—were fully aware (and appreciative) of crossover loyalties to the athletes.
The U.S. team was filled with players who work for Canadian-based NHL teams, and visa versa. And it hasn’t been that long—maybe 50 years–since Canadians overwhelmingly peopled all NHL teams, the majority of which represented U.S. cities. A New York Rangers fan, Chicago Blackhawks fan, Detroit Red Wings fan, Boston Bruins fan, in rooting for his or her home team really was rooting for “our Canadians against your Canadians.” The father of superstar Connor McDavid, whose overtime goal won the Four Nations trophy for Canada, in fact was reportedly a big Boston Bruins fan. Cross-border allegiance, neighborly appreciation.
I thought of Corky DeGraauw, who was a 20-year-old from Toronto playing for the minor-league Long Island Ducks in 1971 when I was assigned to the team’s week-long bus trip to North Carolina and Pennsylvania. DeGraauw thought of how he would prefer flying to road games, “because it’s nice to look down at the ground that you’ve always seen before on maps, and see that there really isn’t a big red line which separates Canada and the U.S….”
We’re neighbors. L Cavanaugh’s Four-Nations summary in the Los Angeles Times mused that “Good neighbors are always there for each other.” He cited how the forestry minister of Canada’s Alberta province had sent firefighters to Los Angeles last month, returning a favor from 2023 when “California firefighters bravely supported Alberta in a time of great need.”
Cavanaugh wrote of “the goons who fought in Montreal” during the preliminary U.S.-Canada match, that “instead of playing their hearts out for their country, they deliberately put themselves in the penalty box. All pain, no gain. But that’s what goons do. They choose the performative over performance, spectacle over contribution, me over we—the exact opposite of what the legendary gold-medal winning 1980 U.S. Olympic hockey team was all about” amid its “Miracle on Ice” upset of the Soviet Union, that real Evil Empire.
Cavanaugh cited Canadian columnist Pete McMartin of the Vancouver Sun lamenting, “Goodbye America. … I’ve reached that point in our relationship where any admiration I have had for you has been replaced by a new, angry resolve, which is: I won’t consort with the enemy.”
The New York Times quoted a Canadian fan in the crowd for the final that “Canadians are so pumped to win this game. Because we can’t beat Trump, right? It’s the only thing we can beat them at — hockey.”
The match was enormously appealing theatre, given the showdown between the world’s two best national teams on such a highly visible stage—as big as the Olympics, in some ways. “With more than a decade of built-up tension between the two rivals, heat on the ice was inevitable,” according to the New York Times. “But for many, the championship game wasn’t about bragging rights alone.”
That clearly was because of the Trump administration’s economic and geopolitical bullying—the lack of statesmanship and tact fouling the North American air. It was a reminder, as the L.A. Times’ Cavanaugh put it, of goonery in the mix. “Goons never really win,” Cavanaugh wrote, “because they’re all about pulling down others.”